I'm looking to pick up a arcade stick for my Xbox 360 since I am playing VF5FS on pad and it's annoying me. The sticks in the subject are in my budget and I was wondering which overall is the better choice. My understanding is both are full Sanwa stick/buttons, wired, and fairly sturdy. I don't care about the graphics of either, but I do care about being able to replace parts when needed. Both sticks are the same price so just trying to get a feel for the better investment. The last time I invested in sticks was in the PS2/DC days for VF3tb, SC, and Tekken. All Mad Catz products I have ever bought have been trash, but I have heard in recent years they have stepped their game up with certain products. Thanks for any input.